Best Cheese For Roast Beef Sandwich – My Top 5 Picks

Every product is independently reviewed and selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

Everyone gets confused when choosing a specific cheese for making a roast beef sandwich. With so many recipes and possibilities to experiment with a roast beef sandwich, the cheese becomes one of the major ingredients to influence the taste. That’s what we’ll talk about today.

I’ve selected the five best cheese for roast beef sandwich. You will find several types in this review. You can go with any one of them to make the best roast beef sandwich. Let’s not keep you waiting anymore. 

Best Cheese For Roast Beef Sandwich

One particular type of cheese does not have an advantage over the other when it comes to making roast beef sandwiches. So, I’ve tried to keep the list versatile. You can go with the one that suits your taste bud most. 

Provolone Natural Cheese By Sargento

If you have decided to go with provolone, I must suggest the one from Sargento. It’s the best cheese you can get for your sandwich. If you didn’t know already, provolone can be a better choice if you’re trying to cut down calories. 

So, the best way is to stick to natural cheese without any added preservatives. The natural provolone not only offers your sandwich a smoky flavor but increases its taste significantly. 

So, without any further ado, let’s take a look at the top features you can expect from this cheese from Sargento.

Provolone Natural Cheese By Sargento

Top Features 

  • Pre-sliced
  • No antibiotics
  • No artificial flavors
  • Easy open and close bag
  • No added growth hormones

Check today’s price on Amazon

BrandSargento Foods
Weight0.5 Pounds
SpecialtyNatural cheese slices

If you’re thinking about sandwiches, pre-sliced cheese is the first thing that pops up in the mind. You won’t have to slice a piece of cheese into the perfect shape when you’re choosing Sargento. 

If you wish to enjoy true Italian flavor in your sandwich, this is the brand to choose. You will be getting 12 perfectly sliced pieces of cheese in one pack delivered to you. 

Moving on to natural taste, this brand trumps any other brand. There are no artificial flavors mixed into the cheese to make it more lucrative. The authentic and natural cheese is so amazing itself that it doesn’t require any additive. 

In addition, you will be relieved to know that it’s entirely derived from milk, instead of adding antibiotics. There are no added growth hormones either. 

So, you must be wondering what is in that cheese? Only the thing that 100% natural cheese contains. There is cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, and annatto. 

Annatto is a vegetable color, derived from plants. As you can see, this cheese is as natural as it gets. 

If you’re thinking about making a roast beef sandwich with perfect smoky cheese, Sargento provolone cheese is the perfect option to go to. One other thing might seem small to a lot of users. 

But in my opinion, the brand provides satisfying packaging. You can store the cheese in the pack using the easy open and close method. 

However, the manufacturer does recommend you consume the cheese within five days of opening the package. This way, you’ll be able to enjoy the best pizza with ultimate freshness. 

By selecting this cheese, you’re not only ensuring a perfect roast beef sandwich but also opening doors to making other delicious recipes. 

For instance, you can make excellent provolone chickens and calzones using this cheese. 

Anything that requires a piece of provolone cheese will certainly have the best outcome with this particular brand. So, there’s no reason not to choose this cheese. 


  • Contains authentic Italian flavors
  • Perfectly thick slices for sandwiches
  • Mild taste, does not overpower any dishes
  • Melts smoothly,  adds much creaminess
  • User-friendly packaging


  • Expires too soon

Sargento Natural Pepper Jack Cheese

I think I’ve already established why you can trust the brand Sargento. Now, it’s time to review another cheese from the same brand. This one is natural pepper jack cheese and can offer you just the flavor you’re seeking. 

As taste differs from person to person, if you’re not a provolone person, pepper jack is the one I will recommend for you. So, why should you go for this particular one? 

Take a look at the top features first and I will tell you why in a minute.

Sargento Natural Pepper Jack Cheese

Top Features 

  • No antibiotics
  • No artificial flavors
  • Natural ingredients
  • No growth hormones
  • Most suited for roast beef sandwiches, turkey, and crackers

Check today’s price on Amazon

Weight0.47 Pounds
VarietyPepper Jack

I’ve already discussed a lot about the brand Sargento. The basic features are almost identical for all cheeses offered by the brand. 

For instance, you can expect the absence of artificial growth hormone in all of their products. So, this one is also entirely safe to consume. 

The packaging is re-sealable, which means you won’t need any container to keep this cheese.

The pieces come pre-sliced so that you can instantly add them to your recipes with even slices. If you’re cooking a turkey and need to add an amazing flavor to it, having a jack pepper cheese pack from Sargento will make your day. 

And that’s only the side benefit of it. You can create the perfect roast beef sandwich using this magnificent cheese. 

No artificial flavor is added to this cheese. So, anything you taste comes from 100% natural ingredients. This jack pepper cheese specifically includes pasteurized milk, cheese culture, hot peppers (jalapeno and habanero Peppers), Salt, and Enzymes. 

If you are only expecting the best flavors and textures in your cheese, Sargento is the way to go. The user reviews will certainly back my words. You will notice the pack going empty faster than anticipated. 

So, get ready, order a pack of jack pepper from Sargento and you will have the best cheese for roast beef sandwiches in your hand.  


  • Safe and healthy to consume
  • Quite soft, melts beautifully 
  • Full of natural flavors and deliciousness
  • Affordable for everyone


  • Doesn’t stay fresh for long

Cheddar Mild Pre-Sliced Cheese

If we are moving to cheddar, I must say that Whole Foods Market is the brand I will prefer. Their mild cheddar can be the perfect addition to your sandwich. Besides, if you want to amp up the flavor of a roast beef sandwich, cheddar like this will be a clear winner. 

There are several reasons to trust the brand when it comes to cheddar cheese. One solid reason is that the brand is backed by thousands of users. You will mostly find users saying good things about the cheddar. Of course, there will be a few negative ones. 

For now, let’s stick to the top features you can expect from this mild cheddar.

Cheddar Mild Pre-Sliced Cheese

Top Features 

  • Pre-sliced
  • Vegetarian
  • Natural ingredients
  • Rich in texture and flavor
  • Suitable for burgers and sandwiches

Check today’s price on Amazon

Brand365 by Whole Foods Market
Weight0.5 Pounds
Allergen InformationMilk

Cheddar is unique on its own. When you combine it with a roast beef sandwich, it blooms to its highest. 

You will only enjoy the best natural taste because there are no artificial flavors added to the cheese. The cheese also melts perfectly. However, some users have complained about the cheese breaking easily. 

If you’re thinking about reasons why you should go for this particular brand, allow me to offer some insights.

First of all, thousands of people favor this brand and will back up the brand’s claim with their experiences. Cooking enthusiasts will certainly tell you that cheddar is one of the best cheese for roast beef sandwich. 

Another thing you should take into consideration is that it comes pre-sliced. 8 ounces of cheese is cut into 10 beautiful slices that are ready to be added to your perfect recipes. 

The slices also come in a re-sealable bag so if you don’t need the entire amount right away, you can conveniently store it in the refrigerator. 

The ingredients are pretty straightforward in this cheese. There is cultured pasteurized milk, enzymes, salt, and Annatto, which is a plant-based color. 

So, as you can see, you can consume the cheese with peace of mind. There are no added hormones or GMOs in the cheese. 

The price, of course, is another significant issue when it comes to choosing the perfect cheese. With Whole Foods Market, you’re certainly going to get the best deal available in the market. 


  • Its creaminess is great for burgers, sandwiches and macaroni cheese
  • Adds a sharp taste and a bit spiciness to your food, making it more flavorful
  • Stays fresh for days
  • Melts perfectly


  • Some people might find the taste a bit too overpowering

Happy Belly Swiss Cheese By Amazon Brand

Another excellent option to go for is swiss cheese. It can offer a smoky and mild taste in your sandwich with the right amount of softness. If you’re going for swiss cheese, make sure that you’re choosing the brand Happy Belly. 

They’ll certainly offer you the freshest dairy product to keep the customers happy. You can get the perfect mellow texture in your sandwich if you decide to go for this one. 

Before jumping to the review, let’s take a quick scan of the top features of this cheese. 

Happy Belly Swiss Cheese By Amazon Brand

Top Features 

  • Affordable price
  • Comes pre-sliced
  • Source of calcium
  • Natural ingredients
  • Soft and creamy texture

Check today’s price on Amazon

BrandHappy Belly
Weight0.5 Pounds
Package Weight0.24 Kilograms

This swiss cheese from Happy Belly is everything you want in a slice of cheese and more. There’s no reason not to go for this cheese, considering the texture, taste, and flavor you’ll be getting. 

Rest assured that your roast beef sandwich game is about to upgrade to an upper level. You will feel the cheese melt inside your mouth with the softest stimulation ever. 

The pre-sliced feature is something I find very convenient. Even though there are other options that come as a whole, I selected all five kinds of cheese in my list are sliced. One significant reason behind this is convenience. 

I’m specifically reviewing the cheese types that are suitable for making a roast beef sandwich. So, when a sandwich requires cheese, it’s always better to go with sliced ones. This way, you’ll be able to save time and store the cheese with ease.

Because this cheese is made from natural ingredients, it will work as a great source of calcium. However, one thing I must mention is the level of saltiness. 

Most users expect swiss cheese to be comparatively saltier than others. However, this one isn’t salty up to the expectation. If you’re thinking from a healthy point of view, it can help you maintain a low sodium diet. 

All in all, it can be a great option if you want the perfect texture inside your sandwich. 


  • Rich and creamy texture makes it perfect for sandwiches
  • Adds a luscious flavor to food
  • Easy to open and store
  • Great for health and helpful for weight loss


  • Milder flavor than expected
  • Doesn’t stay fresh for long

Pre-Sliced Havarti Cheese By Dietz & Watson

The last cheese on my list is a pre-sliced Havarti cheese. If you don’t know much about it, let me tell you. It’s a euro-style cheddar, which is perfect for sandwiches. If you’re expecting a creamy, mildly smoky, and semi-soft texture, you’re in luck. 

That’s precisely what you’ll be getting with Dietz &  Watson.  The brand has a reputation for providing its customers with the freshest products, so you won’t have to worry about that. As for other features, let’s take a look at them. 

Pre-Sliced Havarti Cheese By Dietz & Watson

Top Features 

  • Pre-sliced
  • Gluten-free
  • Mildly smoky
  • Creamy texture
  • Perfect thickness

Check today’s price on Amazon

BrandDietz & Watson
Weight0.5 Pounds
SpecialtyGluten Free

Sometimes you end up with some sheer slices of cheese. Well, that’s not going to be the case when you choose this brand. The perfect thickness will wow you and your guests with its appearance and taste. 

The taste is mildly smoky and the texture is perfectly creamy to feel heaven in your mouth. 

 You won’t find any other Havarti cheese at this price range. Even when you can’t find the perfect cheese for your roast beef sandwich in local stores, this brand will stay loyal by your side with sufficient supply. 

Regardless of how you’re utilizing this cheese, you won’t be disappointed. You can combine it with any sandwiches, crackers, or simply serve it alone. The gluten-free feature is certainly a cherry on top for this product. 

The ingredients are natural and it’s derived from milk. So, it’s got a great nutritious value that you can add to your diet. 

Considering the features you are getting and the price this brand is offering, this is certainly one of the best cheese for cold/hot roast beef sandwich. 


  • Perfect for all savory dishes
  • A budget-friendly option
  • Comes in a great packaging
  • Contains natural and nutritious ingredients, and thus, is healthy
  • Melts fast and evenly, ensuring a hassle free cooking


  • Not creamy enough

What To Look For Before Buying The Best Cheese For Roast Beef Sandwich

If you are a beginner, it’s normal to get confused between cheese types. So, to help you out with some info, I’ve structured a guideline mentioning the feature worth considering, when you’re buying cheese. Keep reading and you will know how to evaluate cheese. 


Luckily for you, most cheese types work great with sandwiches. However, there are a few options that work better than others. 

For instance, you won’t regret choosing a piece of cheddar, Havarti, swiss cheese, or Provolone. These will do wonders to any recipe, including a roast beef sandwich. 

The flavors are excellent. However, they are different from each other. For instance, if you want the meltiest texture, I would recommend you to go with cheddar. 

In comparison, if you seek smokiness, Provolone is a better choice. And if you’re a fan of mildly smoky flavors, go for Havarti. 

Package Size

As you know, cheese doesn’t come with a long expiry date. So, it’s always better to buy fresh before consumption. Almost all cheese types will stay fresh for about five days after you open the bag. So, make sure you’re considering that before ordering a bulk amount. 

Pre-Sliced or Not

I always recommend going for pre-sliced cheese, especially if you’re making sandwiches. It seems like a lot of trouble to go through to cut slices before each use. Besides, if you’re manually cutting the slices, the measurement won’t be even each time. 

Cheese that comes pre-sliced is convenient in every way. They are instantly usable, easy to store, and can offer consistency. Besides, the thickness is always up to the mark when sliced by professionals. 


Cheese should always be natural. Growth hormones can be harmful to your health. So, make sure to check the ingredient list before clicking the purchase button.

It’s also a good idea to stay away from any artificial flavor that can mess up the original taste of the cheese. 

Using external color is a common practice in cheese and it’s done in a healthy way. Most of the time, plant-based colors are used to provide the cheese with an aesthetically pleasing look, without using harmful additives.  

Don’t forget to make sure that the cheese is made using milk. Cheese can also be made in other ways. 

However, as long as you are not lactose-intolerant, you should check the descriptions and ensure that it’s a milk-made cheese. Natural cheese can be a great source of vitamins and calcium. 

User Reviews

If you’re having second thoughts about any product, you can always take a look at the user reviews. It’s a great source of honest information. 

Food products are always risky to buy because you don’t know whether they will suit your taste bud or not. Checking the user reviews can certainly help in this case and facilitate the decision-making procedure. 


You can rest assured that I have included all the best cheese for roast beef sandwiches in this review. As you know, a slice of cheese can break or make the case when it comes to sandwiches. So, if you want to make sure that your sandwich can be served in the most delicious way possible, selecting the suitable cheese is a must. Do your research before jumping into a decision if you didn’t like any of the cheese I listed above. Use the buying guide to check if the cheese is up to the mark for your roast beef sandwich.

Leave a Comment