Best Roasting Pan For Prime Rib With Lid & Rack – Top 5 Picks In 2022

Cooking enthusiasts have a ‘no compromise’ policy when it comes to the things they love. Prime rib is one of the most special things someone can prepare. That’s why it’s crucial that everything goes well.

Every product is independently reviewed and selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

What cutlery you’re using to make a prime roast has a great impact on the recipe. So, I’ve decided to review the best roasting pan for prime rib today. 

After reading today’s post, you’ll find out the perfect options you can consider to give your prime rib the ending it deserves. 

Review Of The Best Roasting Pan For Prime Rib

After careful consideration, I’ve selected the five best options you can go for. All these roasting pans are top-notch in every aspect. Regardless of which one you go for, you know that you will be getting a great one. So, let’s get started, shall we? 

Circulon Nonstick Roasting Pan With Rack

There are thousands of roasting pans with a variety in prices. This one comes within an affordable price range. There are cheaper options available. However, if you’re searching for a roasting pan with some standard features, there can’t be a better option than this one. 

Considering the material type, size, and price point, this is one of the best roasting pans for prime rib that you can find on the market. But more on that later. First, let’s take a look at the top features that this pan has to offer.

Top Features 

  • U-shaped rack 
  • Affordable price
  • Fast and even heating
  • High-temperature tolerance
  • Nonstick alloy steel material

Check today’s price on Amazon

SpecificationsParameters
ManufacturerMeyer
Item Dimensions17 x 13 x 6.5 inches
Item Weight6 Pounds
MaterialAlloy Steel
ColorGray

An all-rounder pan that can satisfy all types of users is hard to come by. This pan from Circulon can keep your greedy heart at peace, especially when you’re cooking prime ribs. 

The pan size is essential when it comes to cooking a prime rib. If you’re choosing this pan, you won’t have to worry about the size at all. It can hold a 24-pound turkey inside it, so you will be okay with your prime rib. 

The curved rack is what makes it the best roasting pan with rack. It keeps the food away from the bottom so that the entire piece is evenly cooked. And speaking of evenly cooked dishes, the alloy steel makes sure that the heat is getting distributed evenly. 

If you decide to go for this pan, you will not only be selecting this for prime rib. You can cook a variety of recipes using the same pan. It’s also pretty easy to use with the handles. The rack also comes with handles to maneuver it with ease. 

High-quality cookware must come with a tolerance for higher temperatures. This pan ensures that you can reach your desired temperature level without waiting for an eternity. 

In addition, you can also use this in an oven. The pan is oven-safe for up to 450 degrees. So, you can get as versatile as you want with your recipe. Overall, this is one of the best products in this category. 

The pan also comes with a lifetime warranty from the manufacturer. However, this warranty does not cover much, which disappointed a lot of users. 

Pros 

  • Reaches high heat in less time 
  • Oven-safe up to 450 degrees F
  • Comes at an affordable price range
  • Distributes the heat evenly through the pan
  • There’s a curved rack included with the pan

Cons

  • The warranty does not cover much

All-Clad Dishwasher Safe Large Rib Roasting Pan

All-Clad has always been a trustworthy brand among chefs for all clad cookware, bakeware and kitchen utensils. The brand has been in the market for so long that other brands hardly come close to the customer base they have. So, you can imagine why you can trust this pan over its competitors. But the question is, what’s the downside?

There’s almost always a flaw when it comes to a man-made product. With this one, it’s the price. Compared to the other pans that I’ll be reviewing, the price of this one resides on the higher side. 

However, if you’re willing to spend this much amount on your pan, there’s no reason not to go with this. 

Top Features 

  • Roasting rack
  • Nonstick surface
  • 20 lbs weight capacity
  • Stainless steel material
  • Compatible with almost all stoves

Check today’s price on Amazon

SpecificationsParameters
ManufacturerGroupe SEB
Item Dimensions18.5 x 14.49 x 6.3 inches
Item Weight8 Pounds
MaterialStainless Steel
Finish TypeNon-stick

I’ve already talked about the brand image. Now, let’s dive into the features of this pan. First of all, the material is high-quality stainless steel. This material is ideal for retaining heat and reflecting it evenly to the food. 

One thing that catches your eyes is that the pan features tall walls around it. Why is that important? 

No matter how messy your recipe is, the walls will prevent any spills or scatters throughout the entire process. That’s not something you can get from all pans. 

The next thing I’m about to highlight is the handles. Those are made very convenient to use. You can lift and move them around with you at all times. They’re upright and secured tightly in place. The space is broad enough for you to move the pan even with oven mitts. 

The rack inside the pan is shaped like V. This ensures that you get the most space out of the pan. And speaking of space inside the pan, you can easily accommodate 20 lbs in the pan. 

So, along with cooking delicious prime rib recipes, the pan will also be an excellent addition when cooking an entire turkey. 

Most roasting pans aren’t dishwasher-safe and hence difficult to clean. This is one of the exceptional ones that you can clean using your dishwasher. 

For many people, this feature is a make-it-or-break-it deal. So, if you’re someone who does not like to wash their crockeries by hand, this is the one to go for. 

One thing that most of the pans don’t offer is stove compatibility. This stainless steel pan is compatible with all stovetops. However, you can’t use it on induction. If you’re considering all the attributes, the only downside of this pan has to be the price. 

So, if you have a handsome budget for your prime rib roasting pan, I’ll certainly recommend this one over the others. 

Pros 

  • Weight capacity of 20 lbs
  • Dishwasher-safe and easy to clean
  • Easy to maneuver with convenient handles
  • High-quality material makes the pan durable 
  • The V-shaped rack enhances the functionality 
  • You can use it with all stovetops except induction

Cons

  • It’s an expensive choice compared to others

Nonstick Easy Cleaning Roasting Pan With Rack

If you’re not into fancy features and want something simple, this is the pan you should choose. Before anything else, I would like to emphasize the price. This is not only affordable but also extremely cheap compared to what other pans ask for. It certainly has a lower price point but the functionality is not low. You will be very happy if you are not into premium cookware. 

Overall, this is a simple, affordable, and convenient roasting pan to cook your prime rib with perfection. More on that later. First, let’s see the features you can expect to get from this pan. 

Top Features 

  • Easy to clean
  • Nonstick finish
  • Alloy steel material 
  • Extremely affordable 
  • Removable roasting rack

Check today’s price on Amazon

SpecificationsParameters
ManufacturerMeyer
Item Dimensions16 x 11.25 x 2.5 inches
Item Weight3 Pounds
MaterialAlloy Steel
ColorGray

Not everyone wants to spend a large amount of money on their roasting pan. If you’re one of the users who are searching for an affordable pan to cook their prime rib, I’ve got you covered. 

This is the cheapest pan to make my list. Note that there are other cheap options available in the market. However, I’ve only kept the best option on this list. 

So, you can rest assured that you’ll be getting a worthy piece for your kitchen. Let’s talk about what makes this pan worthy other than the price. 

The thing I like most about this pan is that the price doesn’t compromise the quality. You still get high-quality alloy steel that lasts a long time.

However, there have been complaints from users about the nonstick coating. That’s the only flaw in this pan. 

Unlike expensive pans, the rack that you get with this one isn’t curved. Unless you’re extremely precise about what you want in your roasting pan, this isn’t a deal-breaker. 

It keeps the meat lifted from the bottom, which allows the meat to drip extra fat into the pan. The rack also fits perfectly. So, it won’t rattle or cause any inconvenience while you cook. 

Along with being extremely easy to clean due to the nonstick surface, the pan is also oven-safe up to 450 degrees F. You can go diverse with your pan without worrying whether it will pass the test of temperature or not.  

The handles are pretty convenient too. Overall, if you’re searching for an affordable option, this is one I will suggest.

Pros 

  • Strong handles 
  • Affordable price 
  • Big enough to cook large meat portions 
  • Easy to clean because of the nonstick surface 
  • The rack keeps the meat lifted from the bottom for dripping 

Cons

  • The nonstick coating is not as durable as the others

Viking 3 In 1 Roasting Pan With Lid

I’m about to introduce you to a super-roasting pan now. If you have this much budget for your pan, you will certainly want this in your kitchen. The reasons aren’t limited to a few. This pan is created for users who are passionate about cooking and know their pots and pans by heart. 

The first thing I would love to point out about this product is the lid. Unlike most other pans, this one comes with a lid, which makes it the best roasting pan with a lid. 

There are, of course, other features to fall in love with. But before that, let me mention the top features first. 

Top Features 

  • 8.5-quart capacity
  • Unique oval shape
  • Compatible with all stoves
  • Comes with a rack and a lid
  • Rolled edge for drip-free pour

Check today’s price on Amazon

SpecificationsParameters
ManufacturerViking Culinary
Item Dimensions19 x 11.25 x 7.25 inches
Capacity8.5 Liters
MaterialStainless Steel
ColorSilver

Let me elaborate on the first feature I have mentioned. When a pot or pan is said to be compatible with all stovetops, it almost always means that it’s not induction compatible. 

Some products specifically say that they’re compatible with all stovetops, except induction. This one, however, is an exception. It’s compatible with all stoves, including induction. 

The next thing that struck me the most is the construction. 3-ply stainless steel makes the pan more durable than ever. 

In addition, it’s oval in shape to facilitate roasting all types of meat. The rolled-up edges are just the cherry on top. You won’t make a mess while pouring using this pan. 

The large capacity makes it one of the most versatile pans ever. You can roast, saute, or cook anything you want using this pan. In addition, the capacity increases when you’re using the lid to cook your food. 

There’s also a rack that comes with this pan to keep the food elevated from the bottom. This, along with the stainless steel material ensures even heating with perfect outcomes. 

Another thing this pan offers the users that other pans don’t is how beautiful it looks. The mirror finish allows you to use the pan as a serving bowl to make your work easier than before. Fewer utensils mean fewer things to wash. So, it’s beneficial from that aspect too. 

Pros 

  • Can also be used as a serving bowl
  • The pan accompanies a lid and a rack
  • The edges prevent dripping while pouring
  • An oval-shaped pan is convenient for cooking
  • Compatible with all cooktops, including induction

Cons

  • Comparatively smaller than other options

Cuisinart Triple Ply Rib Roasting Pan

Everyone has heard of Cuisinart because of its constant deliverance of high-quality products. This roasting pan is no exception either. There is no question about the quality they offer. You can trust this pan with your eyes closed, as long as you have the budget for this pan. 

Another great reason for buying a pan from a renowned brand is that they stand behind their products. In case you find a defective one or have any complaints, they’ll certainly assist you with the best service. I’ll review the roasting pan in detail. But first, let’s take a look at the features. 

Top Features 

  • Curved rack 
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Cool grip handles
  • Even heat distribution
  • Triple ply stainless steel construction

Check today’s price on Amazon

SpecificationsParameters
ManufacturerCuisinart
Item Dimensions6.25 x 20.75 x 13.25 inches
Item Weight1 Pounds
MaterialStainless Steel
ColorStainless Steel

You will have a very satisfying warranty policy. So, rest assured that this product will deliver. It comes with sturdy stainless steel construction that ensures multiple convenient features. 

For instance, you will get amazing heat distribution with stainless steel. So, there will be no hotspots or cold spots like traditional cookware. 

Another thing stainless steel is convenient for is the dishwasher-safe feature. If you value this feature in a pan, Cuisinart will not disappoint you. 

Even though the pan does not have a lid, there’s a curved rack to keep your meat away from the bottom. No portion of your prime rib will stay attached to the pan so that the heat reaches all parts evenly. 

Another feature that no other pans on my list have is the cool-grip handles. This is something I’ve always loved in cookware. When you won’t need anything to hold your hot pan, what else can be more convenient than that? 

So, this pan comes with that feature. The handles are convenient and do not require anything to hold them, even when the pan is hot.

It’s large enough to cook a prime rib with ease. However, the weight can take some time to get used to. Other than that, there aren’t many issues that you can find with the pan. 

Pros

  • Even heat circulation 
  • High-quality materials 
  • Comes with a curved rack 
  • Large enough for cooking turkey
  • Dishwasher-safe and convenient to clean

Cons

  • The rack could have been better

What To Look For While Buying The Best Roasting Pan For Prime Rib

You don’t have to worry if none of the options I have reviewed won your heart. You can always compare other products and choose one that specifically suits your needs. 

However, I’m leaving a few attributes that you should consider when shopping for a roasting pan. 

Material 

Material is very important when it comes to cookware. If the pan gets damaged after a few uses, you’ll be regretting the money you spent. To prevent that from happening, you will have to make sure that you’re choosing the right material. 

The ideal materials that you can go for are either alloy steel or stainless steel. Both are excellent choices. You can rely on these materials to be durable and sturdy. 

Size

If you’re purchasing a pan for cooking prime ribs, you must be careful about the size. Not all pans will accommodate a prime rib. Make sure that the pan you’re buying can hold a prime rib with ease. 

Note that buying a pan that’s optimum in size also ensures that you can cook anything you want. The type of recipes you go for often will determine the optimal size for you. 

Accessories

One mandatory accessory for a roasting pan is a rack. The pan you’re choosing should come with a rack. Some pans feature high-quality curved racks for enhanced convenience when you’re cooking. 

The primary job of these racks is to elevate the food from the surface. This ensures two essential aspects. It allows the extra fat to drip off from the meat. 

In addition, because the food stays touch-free, the heat circulation inside the pan cooks the meat evenly. 

If you need a lid with the pan, make sure to select a product that comes with a lid. Many users assume that the lid is something the brand provides with the product, even though the description says otherwise. 

That’s not true. A lid is considered an additional accessory when you’re shopping for a roasting pan. 

Brand Image 

When you have a big budget for your roasting pan, make sure that you’re buying it from a reputed brand. Even if something goes wrong or you get a damaged product, you will get a great service in this case. On the contrary, if you get a pan from a random brand, it may not deliver the level you were expecting. 

User Reviews

The last thing to check for is the reviews. People who have used the product will better be able to describe their experience than the product description. However, make sure not to get carried away. 

The first thing is, that people seldom review a product when they have a good experience with a product. 

On the contrary, users who have a negative experience always seem to leave a review. In addition, there are also fake reviews put there by the brand or the competitors. So, it’s never easy to be certain. 

What Size Roasting Pan For Prime Rib

There is a lot of size variety when you’re purchasing a pan. However, when you want a particular pan suitable for prime rib, the size becomes a bit specific. Always check the pan and make sure that it will be able to hold a prime rib. 

As you know, a prime rib can weigh anywhere between 12 lbs and 16 lbs. So, you will have to get a pan that can hold this much weight and comes with the respective length. 

Best Type Of Roasting Pan For Prime Rib

The best type of roasting pan you can go for when cooking prime rib is the one that comes with a rack. The sides should be risen to avoid any inconvenience when cooking the prime rib. Also, make sure that the pan is oven-safe up to a specific temperature. 

Can You Cook Prime Rib In A Roasting Pan

Roastings pans are the ideal choice for cooking a prime rib due to a few reasons. For instance, the rack is a great help. The risen sides also help you with the procedure. Note that you can also use a baking pan to cook prime rib. 

Do You Need A Roasting Rack For Prime Rib

The rack with a roasting pan is a nice feature to have when you’re versatile in your cooking methods. However, when you’re cooking a prime rib, it is not a mandatory feature. The rib can stand on its own and act as a natural rack. So, the roasting rack isn’t compulsory for prime ribs. 

Conclusion

Even though you want the best roasting pan for prime rib, I highly suggest that you get a pan that you can get versatile with. You should be able to cook all types of recipes using the same roasting pan. There are plenty of durably, sturdy, and functional products available in the market. You just have to find the one that suits you the most.